The Order You Write This Week: Five Questions to Answer Before You Sign

One of the largest jewelers in the UK asked us the question every jeweler asks this time of year: what do we order for holiday? The answer was already in their data. Nobody had the hours to read it.

That is true for most independents we work with. The sales history, the stock report and the want list all exist. What is missing is the time to turn them into a decision before the vendor is standing at the counter. Here are the five questions we ask before any order is signed, and how to answer each one with what you already have.

1. Budget: how much can you spend before you see a single piece?

Start with open-to-buy. Take the sales you plan, add the stock you want left at the end, then subtract the stock you already have and what is already on order. What remains is the money you are free to spend. Work it out by category, not as one number. Bridal, fashion, gold basics and watches do not move at the same pace, and a single budget hides that.

2. Sell-through: what actually sold through?

Look at annual turn, style by style, over the same twelve months and the same case. A few styles will turn well over once a year, and a few will barely move. Buy into what proved itself, not what you love. If you can only pull one report before the show, make it this one.

3. Asked for: what did customers ask for that you did not have?

Your want list and your sales notes already hold the gaps in your case. A yellow gold tennis bracelet that keeps turning up on the want list is a buying decision waiting to be made. Count the requests, rank them, and take that list with you.

4. ROI: which vendor pays you back?

The vendor who sells the most is not always the vendor who earns you the most. In an illustrative example, one vendor returns $0.70 for every $1 of stock you hold, while a smaller one returns $1.40. That measure is gross margin return on inventory, and 39% of independent jewelers cannot state theirs, according to the INSTORE Big Survey 2024. Rank your vendors by the margin you earn for every dollar of their stock you hold, and let that guide who gets the larger share of the budget.

5. Exit: how does this piece leave if it does not sell?

Plan the sell-down before you sign, and agree it with the vendor where you can. On day one, show it in the case, not the drawer. At three months, feature it in the window, on social, or with a staff incentive. At six months, move it to another case or another store. At nine months, promote it with an event, a gift with purchase or a bundle. At twelve months, mark it down or swap it toward a new order. At eighteen months, remount or melt. Timings and terms vary by category and vendor, but a piece with no exit plan tends to become a piece in the drawer.

Where AI comes in

None of this needs code. You need your sales history, your stock and one clear question, such as "Build my spring open-to-buy by category from the last two years," or "Rank my vendors by the margin I earn for every dollar of their stock I hold." AI does the heavy lifting on forecasting, buy planning and the number crunching. People still decide. If you use a general AI tool with business data, use a business plan with training on your data switched off. We are also building a system that lives inside a jeweler's own data, so nothing gets uploaded.

You do not need to be big to do this. A card for every vendor, completed before every buying visit, will tell you more about your next order than instinct alone. Your instinct is your memory. The card adds what that memory forgets, including what each piece cost you to sell.

Take the worksheet with you. We built the Buying Worksheet for Elle's JA New York session. It has one card per vendor and works out open-to-buy, turn and ROI, with the sell-down plan and the five AI questions built in. Open the Buying Worksheet. To find out where AI would pay your business back first, email us at inquiry@hillandco.co

Sources: INSTORE Big Survey 2024 (39% of independent jewelers cannot state their GMROI). Vendor return figures and turn examples are illustrative, as shown in the JA session.

Next
Next

Playing with AI Is Not the Same as Building with It